The Best Restaurants in Hillsdale, NJ (2025 Guide)
If you’re searching for the best restaurants in Hillsdale, NJ, you’re in the right place. Hillsdale may be a small town in Bergen County, but it offers a surprisingly diverse dining scene—from homestyle Italian kitchens to vibrant Thai flavors and Mediterranean specialties. At DiscoverHillsdale.com, our goal is to highlight local businesses and help residents and visitors find the best places to eat, gather, and enjoy great meals.
Whether you’re planning a date night, grabbing a casual lunch, or exploring new flavors, this guide covers the top restaurants in Hillsdale NJ and what makes each one special. Let’s dive in.
1. Alba Italian Grill – Classic Italian, Modern Comfort
Formerly known as Osso Buco Grill, the newly refreshed Alba Italian Grill continues the tradition of authentic Italian cooking with a warm, inviting dining room and generous portions. Alba blends the charm of a traditional Italian restaurant with a polished presentation that appeals to both longtime residents and newcomers.
Their menu includes favorites like handmade pasta, seafood specials, chicken entrées, and grilled classics. The atmosphere feels upscale yet comfortable, making it perfect for celebrations or relaxed weeknight dinners.
What to try: Chicken scarpariello, seafood pasta, veal osso buco, homemade tiramisu.
Great for: Family dinners, celebrations, Italian comfort food cravings.
2. Fig & Tomato – A Cozy Italian & European Eatery
Located right in the heart of Hillsdale, Fig & Tomato blends classic European flavors with a modern, homestyle touch. Known for its warm atmosphere, BYO dining, and beautifully prepared Italian dishes, it’s a go-to choice for both regulars and visitors discovering Hillsdale’s culinary scene.
The menu features everything from handcrafted pastas to rich seafood entrées and comforting chicken dishes. Their specials change seasonally, making every visit slightly different. Families appreciate the friendly service, while couples often choose Fig & Tomato for a quiet evening out.
If you’re searching for Italian restaurants in Hillsdale NJ, this spot is almost always the first one locals mention.
What to try: Burrata, short rib ravioli, veal dishes, homemade desserts.
Great for: Date nights, family dinners, BYO wine nights.
3. Domani – A Neighborhood Italian Staple
Domani is one of Hillsdale’s classic neighborhood restaurants. It offers a casual-yet-refined dining experience where locals go for generous portions and reliable flavors. It may not be as modern or trendy as some other spots, but it has a loyal following for its consistency, friendly service, and traditional Italian dishes.
Domani is well known for its pasta selections, chicken dishes, and reliable takeout service. If you want a relaxed Italian meal with all the classics—from penne vodka to chicken parm—Domani is a solid and timeless choice.
What to try: Pasta vodka, chicken francese, calamari, baked dishes.
Great for: Casual dinners, takeout, family nights.
4. Koon Thai Eatery – Fresh, Flavorful Thai Cuisine
For those looking to try something beyond Italian fare, Koon Thai Eatery is a gem. With a cozy interior and a menu filled with bold flavors, it brings a refreshing diversity to the Hillsdale dining scene. The freshness of the ingredients and the balance of sweet, spicy, and savory flavors make it a favorite among food lovers across Bergen County.
From noodles to curries to stir-fry dishes, Koon Thai offers authentic Thai comfort food that’s consistently delicious. It’s also a popular takeout option for busy weeknights.
What to try: Pad Thai, Panang curry, drunken noodles, pineapple fried rice.
Great for: Quick lunches, flavorful dinners, takeout.
5. Atlantis Mediterranean Grill House – A Taste of the Mediterranean
Just a short distance from Hillsdale’s center, Atlantis Mediterranean Grill House brings fresh Mediterranean flavors to Broadway. With a menu built around grilled meats, fresh vegetables, and house-made sauces, it is a perfect spot for anyone looking for something hearty yet healthy.
The restaurant offers everything from Greek-style platters to kebabs, gyros, salads, and seafood selections. The portions are generous, and the flavors are authentic—making it a standout option when you want something both satisfying and refreshing.
What to try: Mixed grill platter, lamb kebab, hummus, chicken shawarma.
Great for: Healthy meals, Mediterranean lovers, families.
Why These Restaurants Stand Out in Hillsdale NJ
Hillsdale’s dining scene continues to grow, and these restaurants cover the full spectrum—from Italian comfort traditions to flavorful Thai dishes and Mediterranean specialties. What makes these eateries truly special is their strong connection to the community. Many are family-owned, long-established, or beloved local spots that contribute to Hillsdale’s charm.